1Not many of you should become teachers, my brothers, for you
know that we who teach will be judged with greater strictness. 2For
we all stumble in many ways, and if anyone does not stumble in what he says, he
is a perfect man, able also to bridle his whole body. 3If we put
bits into the mouths of horses so that they obey us, we guide their whole
bodies as well. 4Look at the ships also: though they are so large
and are driven by strong winds, they are guided by a very small rudder wherever
the will of the pilot directs. 5So also the tongue is a small
member, yet it boasts of great things.
How great a forest is set ablaze by such a small
fire! 6And the tongue is a fire, a world of unrighteousness. The
tongue is set among our members, staining the whole body, setting on fire the
entire course of life, and set on fire by hell. 7For every kind of
beast and bird, of reptile and sea creature, can be tamed and has been tamed by
mankind, 8but no human being can tame the tongue. It is a restless
evil, full of deadly poison. 9With it we bless our Lord and Father,
and with it we curse people who are made in the likeness of God. 10From
the same mouth come blessing and cursing. My brothers, these things ought not
to be so. 11Does a spring pour forth from the same opening both
fresh and salt water? 12Can a fig tree, my brothers, bear olives, or
a grapevine produce figs? Neither can a salt pond yield fresh water.
A WARNING TO
TEACHERS
“Not many of you
should become teachers, my brothers, for you know that we who teach will be
judged with greater strictness.” The
opening to chapter three seems like something of an odd transition from “For as
the body apart from the Spirit is dead, so also faith apart from works is
dead.” But we must first need to understand
where James is heading with his opening statement. James is going to break into an examination
of “the tongue”, a.k.a how we use our words. James is beginning with a specific example, i.e. teachers, and from
there he’ll transition into a more general discussion on the tongue.
Anyone who wishes
to assume a place of instruction to the church body, at any age level, must
first come with a great reverence for the nature and word of God. James isn’t saying, “Don’t become teachers.” This would be a foolish statement and it
would be contrary to the rest of scripture. What he is saying is that if you desire to teach then you must first
understand the full weightiness of what it means to teach God’s word to others. If you take it lightly then you could do
immeasurable amounts of damage even if you have the best of intentions. Most people are designed to follow but few
are designed to lead. We would probably
all agree that it takes a certain kind of person to lead and this is not a
position that many people aspire to. There is a great and unique kind of gravity that comes with teaching
others. If you mess it up then you will
have much to answer for because if you’re leading people away from the light of
God’s truth rather than leading them toward it, not only are you committing
sin, you are leading others down a path of self-indulgent sinfulness. I think this is why James says, “…for you
know that we who teach will be judged with greater strictness.” If you have sinned in your guidance of others
and have in turned caused those who trust your word, not so much the explicit
word of God, to live non-God centered lives, then woe to you when the deeds of
your days are counted and judged. I have
taken this warning very near to my heart ever since I have started
teaching. Anyone who teaches must take
careful pains to preach only what God’s word explicitly details. This is what I mean when I say teach with
reverence. So with every word we speak
about God we must do it in the spirit of venerating the vast greatness of the
Lord that is ruler of our lives.
ALL STUMBLE
Verse 2 gives
support for verse 1. You can almost
imagine a question between verse 1 & 2. What other reasons should cause us to tread with great caution when we
seek to teach? Verse 2 would be the
perfect response to that question. This
verse illustrates,very aptly,the natural fallibility that exists in the verbal
dealings of all people. “For we all
stumble in many ways, and if anyone does not stumble in what he says, he is a
perfect man, able also to bridle his entire body.” There is no area of our lives where we can
say that we are perfect. It is in fact a
mere statement of truth that we all stumble in many ways. Our usage of language is no exception to this
rule. It is true that we may exhibit
great discipline in varying areas of our lives but there is always a place in
everyone’s existence where they exhibit very little self-discipline. One of the most commonly found undisciplined
areas of our lives is our usage of language. By language I don’t mean ill use of grammar or bad dialect. I’m simply referring to how we speak. What do we talk about? What do our words dwell upon? How do our words affect others? This isn’t just discussion about gossip. That is a short sighted perspective of this
section of James. While gossip could
certainly be, and most likely will be, discussed in this section, it is not the
overriding theme of importance to grab onto.
The great point of
realization in this section is that the tongue is a like a rogue member of our
body that can easily and greatly cause us to fail in our worship and service of
God. We must first acknowledge that our
tongue is a natural force of failure. From there we must proceed to the question of, “How do we combat the nature
of the tongue?” James responds to this
by giving us many illustrations of how the tongue is weak. We must first understand the nature of a
thing before we can truly know how to challenge it. So let’s discover that nature.
DEFINING THE
NATURE OF THE TONGUE
The latter half of
verse 2 says that if someone does not stumble in what they say then they are
perfect and able also to bridle the entirety of their body. This implicates that the tongue is
responsible for much sin that goes on in our lives. Ask yourself if you find this implication to
be a mere illustration of truth or a gross overstatement of what the tongue can
do. If we could “tame the tongue” could
we really better combat the nature of sinful flesh? James seems to be indicating that this is
true.
Consider James
first of two examples: “If we put bits
into the mouths of horses so that they obey us, we guide their whole bodies as
well.” This is a very practical
illustration. Many of us have probably
seen horses guided around by bits that have been harnessed into their
mouths. If the horse is tame you will
see for yourself that the horse’s whole body is guided, essentially, by that
bit in their mouth.
Example 2: “Look at the ships also: though they are so large and driven by strong
winds, they are guided by a very small rudder wherever the will of the pilot
directs.” This is yet another highly
practical illustration. Ships are huge
but without the guidance given to them by their rudder (which is comparatively
smaller than the whole ship) they would be at the mercy of the seas that drift
them.
The point of these
two illustrations is to serve as a support for what James says in verse 5, “So
also the tongue is a small member, yet it boasts of great things.” From this point forward James is going to
transition his message to a broader audience and deal specifically with how the
tongue affects our lives. Though the
tongue may seem like a small and insignificant part of the body, we must
realize that it can be a giant in the worst and best ways. Words mean so much to people and I think that
many of us underestimate how important our linguistic abilities are to our
every day existence. If I suddenly could
not speak tomorrow, my career as a teacher would be over. I would no longer be a worship leader. My whole structure of communication would
change. My life wouldn’t, by any means,
be over but a major transition would have to occur in my life in order to
communicate with the speaking world around me. It is so vital that we take care with our language. We must seek to glorify God with our language
and this is vastly more difficult than most people realize or are at least
willing to admit.
The Tongue Is A
Fire: “How great a forest is set ablaze by such a
small fire! And the tongue is a fire, a
world of unrighteousness. The tongue is
set among our members, staining the whole body, setting on fire the entire
course of life and set on fire by hell.” The metaphor of the tongue as a fire is quite true. Our words can be so consuming and damaging to
others that there is a very real danger that the things another person says to
you can do permanent, or least hard to repair, damage. What’s worse is that James tells us that the
tongue is a harbinger of unrighteousness. The thought of being sinful in any area of our lives should trouble
us. We must always take great care to
speak only in God’s perspective of truth. If we fail to do that then we open up our language to a filthy causeway
of unrighteous usage.
What is James
implying when he says that the tongue is “set among our members, staining the
whole body, setting on fire the entire course of life and set on fire by hell”? I believe that James is trying to illustrate
how the tongue can infect your whole body and your entire course of life. The detrimental affect of this is that it
gives sin an opportunity to rule in every area of your life. This causes us to be false to God’s truth and
to fail in our worship of Him. This is a
state of being that no Christian alive should desire to be in. Sin is a horrible, powerful, and pervasive
device of the enemy. The enemy can use
sin so effectively and this is evidenced very sharply in the case of misuse in
language. To combat this we must seek
God’s word to understand how we can glorify God through language. We must seek to understand how language helps
reveal the righteousness of God. We must
also develop a great care and patience for when and how to speak. All of our words must first proceed from a
love of God and a desire to see His will accomplished in the world. If our words begin to proceed from anywhere
but there we should immediately stop ourselves to refocus on the majesty of God
and how we honor him with our words. It
is only then that we should proceed forward in speech. This is vital to choking out the sinful
nature of the tongue. Our goal in this
struggle should be to discipline our tongue so that it could serve the greater
and higher purpose of God.
There is yet one
more thing in this verse that must be addressed. James uses the phrase “set on fire by hell”
at the conclusion of verse 6. What,
precisely, does this mean? When we
consider the word “hell” our mind may automatically jump to a few different
places. We may think of a place of
eternal separation from God as well as the dominion of Satan. The Bible teaches us that Satan is the father
of lies and that every word that comes from his mouth is a lie (John
8:44). Jesus says that from the
beginning Satan was a murderer and a liar. We see in the book of Genesis, chapter 3 to be exact, that Satan (the
serpent) came to Eve and deceived her with words. Satan made a compelling, though false,
argument and tempted Eve to sin and Eve led her husband into this sin as well
for both ate from the tree of the knowledge of good and evil. The cataclysmic effect of this is well known
to both Christian and non-Christian alike. Words continue to be a colossal tool of the enemy. I’m sure it delights all that is evil every
single time that we sin with our language. I’m sure it delighted Satan in the garden when Eve fell for his repartee
of deception and I’m sure that he was doubly gratified when Adam fell into this
snare. The external danger of words is
as deep and darkly seeded as the internal danger. The story of Adam and Eve shows us the
external danger, and consequence, of words. Speaking lustfully of a man or woman who is not your spouse would be an
example of the internal danger, and consequence, of words. Some people say that words are only words and
that they cannot harm you. The Bible is
quite clear that this is a foolish and dangerous perception of language.
I want to leave
this section with one final note and it is a historical side note that I
believe will help you better understand the biblical usage of the word “hell”. In the original Greek the word translated as
“hell” in the bible was the term Geenna or Gehenna. This term actually referred to a geographical
location near Jerusalem. It was a valley where the filth and dead
animals of the city were dumped and burned. This particular usage of the word, depending
on what translation you’re reading, occurs over 10 times in the New
Testament. Those reading it would have
understood that “hell”, known to them as Gehenna, was referring to a terrible
place of wretched stench and death. This, however, does not indicate that the Bible never speaks of a
literal hell. The Bible speaks
explicitly about a real hell and not just real world locations that we can view
today on a map. Consider 2 Peter 2:4,
“For if God did not spare angels when they sinned, but cast them into hell and
committed them to chains of gloomy darkness to be kept until judgment;”. Though hell is being translated from the
Greek word genna, the context makes it obvious that the hell being referred to
is a place not necessarily of this earth. It is difficult to know the full breadth of hell because the Bible gives
us somewhat limited descriptions of it. Granted, the Bible has given us more than enough context to understand
the general severity of hell but like most things, reading about it and seeing
it with your very own eyes are two entirely different things. Though this may not contribute greatly to
what we’ve been discussing here in James my hope is that you will find some of
this information helpful in discerning the Biblical perspective of hell. Hell is something that many people have
questions about and it is our duty as Christians to be as informed as humanly
possible about things such as these.
Can The Tongue
Be Tamed? “For every kind of bird and beast, of reptile
and sea creature, can be tamed and has been tamed by mankind. But no human being can tame the tongue. It is a restless evil, full of deadly
poison.” The answer to the question
which opened this section is this: No. Verse 8 of chapter 3 very
clearly says this. So the question then
becomes, “If we can’t tame the tongue then what hope do we have of controlling
it?”
The original Greek
term that is translated as “tame” is the word “damazo” which means to tame,
curb, or restrain. Notice the word that
is not used in these definitions. You
don’t hear the word “discipline”. Being
tame and being disciplined are not at all the same thing. To be tame means to be changed from a wild or
savage state to a docile one. Discipline
is the act of training oneself to behave in accordance with rules or
expectations. While we cannot tame the
tongue I do believe that we can discipline the tongue. One of the primary lessons to draw from the
entire letter of James is the fact that we must discipline our lives. James is urging us to live up to an
expectation. He is urging us to
understand what God expects of us and then do whatever those expectations
require. The tongue is no
different. But how do we do this?
Before we can
truly combat something we must first be able to identify what it is that we are
to combat. Therefore, if we do not first
understand the nature of the tongue how can we ever hope to discipline the
slithery thing? That is why James draws
some distinctions in these verses. Human
beings are capable of taming many things. Birds, varying beasts of the forests, reptiles, and sea creatures are
all example of things that can be tamed and have been tamed by human beings. Yet the ability of humans to tame things
should not go to our heads. Though we
can tame many things outside of the body, so many people have an immensely
difficult time disciplining their personal faults. Why is this? In a way it’s a mystery, yet in another way, if we are transparent
enough with ourselves, we will see that many of our failures to discipline
aspects of our character have largely to do with our own ignorance,
stubbornness, and foolish pride. This
has certainly been true in my own history and I can tell you that this
admission is far from easy for me to make. It is essential for us to first understand that the tongue is a fire, a
deadly poison, and a herald of unrighteousness. Coming to grips with those things will help us understand what we are up
against. This will, in turn, help us
understand exactly how and where we need to discipline our tongues. Comprehending the nature of the beast will
assist us in killing it day in and day out.
Duality Must
Not Exist In The Tongue: “With it we bless our
Lord and Father, and with it we curse people who are made in the likeness of
God. From the same mouth come blessing
and cursing. My brothers, these things
out not to be so. Does a spring pour forth
from the same opening both fresh and salt water? Can a fig tree, my brothers, bear olives or a
grapevine produce figs? Neither can a
salt pond yield fresh water.” The lesson
here is exceedingly simple yet very difficult in application. All the examples in verses 9-12 show us how a
lack of discipline in the tongue can create a tremendous contradiction in the
life of a Christian. How can we say,
“God is glorious and wonderful,” yet in the same day also say, “I know this is
terrible to say but that woman has never been faithful to a single man she’s
ever been with…she’s always been kind of a whore.” How can we bless God then turn around and
curse one of His created ones? It
doesn’t make sense. This simply must not
be. We can look in nature and find that
certain things just don’t go together. A
spring will not pour forth both fresh and salt water. It simply doesn’t work that way. Fig trees don’t produce olives. Nature doesn’t work like that. Grapevines don’t produce figs. It is logistically improbable. A pond won’t be half salt water and half
fresh water. Things such as this do not
occur. Why then should blessing and
cursing exist in the same mouth? The
Bible says that it shouldn’t.
Before I close out
this section of the commentary I want to talk briefly about the word
“cursing”. In the original Greek this
word was “katara”. The definition for
this word means to execrate, imprecate, or curse. I had to look the first two of those words
up. To execrate means to utterly detest,
abhor, abominate, damn, or denounce. Those words, hopefully, give you a better idea of how this word is
defined. To imprecate is to invoke or
call down evil (curses) upon a person. A
curse is the expression of a wish that evil, doom, misfortune, etc. would
befall a person. So when you see, “From
the same mouth come blessing and cursing,” please don’t be foolish in thinking
that this is referring to the usage of profanity. I’m not saying that profanity is or should be
acceptable but I also don’t think it needs to be a place of stumbling
either. I occasionally use a profanity
but I have to admit that this study of James is convicting me with a stronger
passion to rid myself of that part of my language. From a cultural perspective we know that
profanity is not tolerated in school systems and it is not acceptable in public
places of business, not to mention the myriad of other places where it is
considered taboo to use profanity. Therefore I have more often asked myself the question, “What is the
point of using profanity at all?” Profanity is an extraneous part of language. There is no setting I can conceive of where
profane words are the only possible choice of vocabulary. So why use them? I find myself unable to answer that
question. Considering all that has been
discussed here, it makes me take a much harder look at the turns of phrase I
choose to exercise.
In the next commentary
I will be concluding chapter 3 with a discussion on wisdom as defined by the
letter of James. We will be specifically
covering verses 13-18. Ask yourself a
few questions:
(1) What
is wisdom?
(2) Is
there a difference between earthly wisdom and the wisdom that comes from
God? If so what is the primary
difference?
(3) What
kinds of things cloud our perception of wisdom?
Those are just a
few things to get you started. We will
delve into some of these in a few weeks.
Recent Comments